paint-brush
Michael Saylor Has Built A House of Cards That Could Tumble Downby@juancguerrero
395 reads
395 reads

Michael Saylor Has Built A House of Cards That Could Tumble Down

by Juan C. GuerreroFebruary 27th, 2025
Read on Terminal Reader
Read this story w/o Javascript

Too Long; Didn't Read

A potential $8.2 billion debt bomb could force the liquidation of nearly 500,000 Bitcoin.

Companies Mentioned

Mention Thumbnail
Mention Thumbnail

Coin Mentioned

Mention Thumbnail
featured image - Michael Saylor Has Built A House of Cards That Could Tumble Down
Juan C. Guerrero HackerNoon profile picture
0-item

When MicroStrategy's stock plummeted 55% from its November high, most focused on the price drop itself. But they missed something far more important: A potential $8.2 billion debt bomb that could force the liquidation of nearly 500,000 Bitcoin.


Here's the uncomfortable truth: MicroStrategy created the most aggressive leveraged Bitcoin position in history, and now the bill might be coming due.


Think about it. Right now:

  • MicroStrategy holds 499,096 Bitcoin worth $43.7 billion
  • They've borrowed $8.2 billion to acquire it
  • Their stock has crashed 55% in three months
  • Their debt covenants have a "fundamental change" clause


But here's what everyone misses: This isn't just about Bitcoin. It's about financial engineering that could collapse.

The Great Bitcoin Gamble

Let's break down what's actually happening:


MicroStrategy's entire business model relies on a flywheel effect:

  1. Borrow money through 0% convertible notes
  2. Buy Bitcoin and drive price higher
  3. Sell new shares at premium and buy more Bitcoin
  4. Repeat


But here's where it gets interesting: This flywheel only works in one direction.

The Debt Structure

Consider MicroStrategy's debt:

  • $8.2 billion in convertible notes
  • Most maturity dates between 2027-2032
  • $3 billion due in 2029 alone
  • Conversion prices ranging from $39.80 to $672.40


These convertible notes contain a critical trigger – a "fundamental change" clause that could force early redemption if shareholders approve "any plan or proposal for the liquidation or dissolution of the Company."

The Technical Trigger

Here's the billion-dollar insight: If Bitcoin's value falls significantly, MicroStrategy's assets could slip below its liabilities, creating a perverse incentive for shareholders.


Think about it:

  • If Bitcoin falls 50%+ and stays down
  • Convertible notes can't be converted (underwater)
  • Debt comes due starting in 2027
  • Shareholders might prefer liquidation to pay themselves first

The Michael Saylor Factor

Saylor currently holds 46.8% of voting power, making a liquidation vote difficult. He insists they wouldn't sell "even if Bitcoin fell to $1."


But this ignores market realities:

  • Creditors have legal rights
  • Stock can't raise capital if it collapses
  • The flywheel needs constant new money
  • Cash flow can't cover interest payments

The Market Verdict

MicroStrategy's stock has experienced wild swings:

  • Up 500% in the Bitcoin bull run
  • Down 55% in the recent correction
  • Now trading around $252, down from $560+ in November


While the company's average Bitcoin purchase price is $66,357, their ability to service debt doesn't depend on being profitable – it depends on continued capital market access.

The Real Questions

The true vulnerabilities aren't about forced liquidation today. They're about:


  • Can MicroStrategy refinance debt in a Bitcoin bear market?
  • Will investors keep buying shares if Bitcoin falls further?
  • What happens when convertible notes mature underwater?
  • How sustainable is a "never sell" strategy with massive debt?

The Bitcoin Cult Factor

As we noted in our analysis of Saylor's approach, he's positioned Bitcoin not as currency but as "digital gold" – a philosophical stance that's created cult-like devotion.


The investment thesis relies on a permanent, upward trajectory. "If Bitcoin reaches $3M it would mean that something really bad is going on out there."


But the flip side is troubling: What if it falls significantly and stays down?

The Potential Endgame

Three scenarios emerge:

  1. Bitcoin rises enough to make all convertible notes profitable, solving the problem
  2. Bitcoin trades sideways, creating refinancing challenges when debt matures
  3. Bitcoin falls significantly, potentially triggering a liquidation decision

The Ultimate Irony

Here's the greatest paradox: While Saylor positions Bitcoin as a hedge against monetary instability, he's built perhaps the most leveraged, fragile Bitcoin position possible.


Welcome to the great MicroStrategy experiment.


The question isn't whether Bitcoin has long-term value. The question is: Can a public company hold billions of it through debt without ever selling?


The flywheel that took MicroStrategy to the moon works in both directions.


And gravity is a powerful force.